Why Healthcare workers Need Stronger Protections

In recent years, our healthcare system has faced unprecedented challenges, with one disturbing trend standing out: the alarming rise in violence in healthcare. Those who dedicate their lives to healing and helping others increasingly find themselves at risk of verbal abuse, physical assault, and psychological trauma while performing their duties.

This growing crisis demands immediate attention and comprehensive solutions to ensure that healthcare workers receive the protections they deserve while providing essential care to patients.

The Growing Crisis of Violence in Healthcare

Healthcare workers face a disproportionate risk of workplace violence compared to employees in other industries. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, violence against healthcare workers increased by 63% between 2011 and 2018—a trend that has only worsened in recent years. The COVID-19 pandemic exacerbated these challenges significantly due to isolation protocols, visitor restrictions, and heightened anxiety.

A 2024 report from National Nurses United revealed that in 2023, an alarming 81.6% of nurses experienced at least one form of workplace violence. Similarly, 91% of emergency physicians reported being threatened or attacked, with 71% believing that violence had worsened compared to previous years.

The spectrum of violence in healthcare settings is broad and includes verbal abuse, psychological violence, threats, physical violence, and sexual harassment.

While this violence can manifest in every healthcare setting, hospital emergency departments often see the highest rates, where patients and families in crisis may lash out during long wait times or when receiving difficult news. Long-term care facilities face unique challenges with patients suffering from dementia or other cognitive impairments who may become unintentionally combative. Even outpatient clinics and physician offices report increasing incidents of verbal aggression and threats, particularly when patients are denied requested medications or treatments

Perhaps most concerning is that research estimates approximately 60% of workplace violence incidents in healthcare go unreported, suggesting the actual prevalence may be significantly higher than documented.

Understanding the Risks in Healthcare Settings

Several factors contribute to making healthcare environments particularly vulnerable to violent incidents. Healthcare workers are often dealing with individuals experiencing extreme stress, pain, or altered mental states. Additionally, hospitals and clinics frequently operate 24/7, sometimes in high-crime areas, with access to controlled substances and valuable equipment.

Hospital safety challenges include:

• Treating patients with histories of violence
• Working in understaffed conditions
• Managing long wait times and overcrowded facilities
• Insufficient security measures
• Inadequate environmental design (poor lighting, limited escape routes)

Not all healthcare professionals face equal risk. Emergency department staff, psychiatric care providers, and those working in home healthcare settings report the highest incidence rates. According to recent studies, 70% of emergency nurses report being hit or kicked on the job, while 61% of home healthcare workers have experienced violent incidents ranging from verbal attacks to physical assaults.

And when healthcare professionals experience violence, patient care suffers. Approximately 80% of emergency physicians confirm that violence in their departments harms patient care quality.

The psychological toll of violence on healthcare workers should not be underestimated. Studies show that repeated exposure to workplace violence contributes significantly to burnout, compassion fatigue, and professional attrition. Many experienced nurses and physicians cite concerns about personal safety as a primary reason for leaving patient-care roles.

This loss of talent creates a dangerous cycle where understaffing leads to increased stress and risk, potentially triggering more violent incidents. The financial impact is also substantial: healthcare facilities spend billions annually on security measures, workers’ comp claims, and recruitment costs to replace staff who leave due to safety concerns.

Current Hospital Safety Measures and Gaps

Many healthcare facilities have implemented basic safety protocols, but these measures often fall short of addressing the true complexity and severity of the problem. Traditional approaches frequently focus on reactive strategies rather than comprehensive prevention, leaving significant gaps in protection.

Common shortcomings in current hospital safety approaches include:

• Reliance on underutilized incident reporting systems
• Limited training in de-escalation techniques
• Insufficient staffing levels that increase risk
• Inadequate physical security infrastructure
• Organizational cultures that normalize violence as “part of the job”

When facilities operate with the misconception that aggression from patients is an occupational hazard, violence is normalized, and implementation of more robust protective measures can be delayed.

The Role of Healthcare Legislation

Legislative efforts at both federal and state levels are critical to creating safer work environments for healthcare professionals. Currently, no comprehensive federal law specifically addresses healthcare safety and workplace violence, though several promising bills have been introduced.

The Workplace Violence Prevention for Health Care and Social Service Workers Act (H.R. 2663) represents a significant potential advancement. Introduced in 2023, this legislation would mandate OSHA to enforce standards regarding workplace violence prevention plans for healthcare and social service employers. The bill would require the development of specific training programs, risk assessment protocols, and reporting systems while protecting workers from retaliation when reporting incidents.

Another critical piece of pending healthcare legislation is the Safety from Violence for Healthcare Employees (SAVE) Act (H.R. 2584/S.2768). This bill would make it a federal crime to assault a hospital worker performing their duties, with potential penalties including fines and imprisonment.

At the state level, 17 states have enacted workplace violence prevention laws specifically for healthcare workers, including Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Illinois, and Texas. These state-level initiatives provide varying degrees of protection, with some requiring comprehensive violence prevention plans while others focus on incident reporting and training requirements.

Texas Senate Bill 240, passed in 2023, represents one of the most comprehensive state-level approaches. This bill requires facilities to implement written workplace violence prevention plans, establish incident response and investigation protocols, enforce reporting requirements, and provide annual staff training.

Best Practices and Solutions

Creating safer healthcare environments requires a multifaceted approach combining organizational policies, physical safeguards, and technological solutions. Effective workplace violence prevention begins with a comprehensive risk assessment to identify specific vulnerabilities within each healthcare setting.

Key components of successful healthcare safety programs include:

1. Comprehensive prevention plans tailored to specific healthcare environments

• Regular risk assessment and environmental evaluations
• Clear reporting protocols with protection from retaliation
• Incident investigation and follow-up procedures

2. Staff training and education

• De-escalation techniques and conflict resolution strategies
• Recognition of potential violence warning signs
• Emergency response protocols for various scenarios

3. Environmental and administrative controls

• Optimized facility design (improved lighting, limited access points)
• Adequate staffing levels, particularly during high-risk times
• Clear visitor policies and access management

4. Technology solutions

• Modern security systems for monitoring and response
• Emergency communication tools for rapid assistance
• Wearable panic buttons and alert systems

Technology plays an increasingly important role in enhancing safety. For example, companies like CENTEGIX offer wearable duress buttons that allow healthcare workers to discreetly signal for help during potentially dangerous situations. Such technologies represent just one component of a comprehensive approach to violence prevention.

The Joint Commission, recognizing the severity, issued updated Workplace Violence Prevention Standards for hospitals in 2021. These standards require healthcare administrators to manage safety risks through worksite analysis, monitor workplace conditions, provide continuous education for staff, and maintain a culture prioritizing safety.

A Commitment to Healthcare Worker Protection

The rising tide of violence in healthcare settings represents a serious threat to both healthcare workers and the patients they serve. Creating safer environments requires a coordinated effort involving healthcare administrators, policymakers, and frontline staff.

Through comprehensive hospital safety protocols, supportive healthcare legislation, and innovative technology solutions, we can better protect those who dedicate their lives to caring for others. Healthcare workers deserve to perform their vital roles without fear of violence or abuse.

The time for stronger protections is now.

Also Read: The Effect of Artificial Intelligence on Modern Healthcare Solutions